Music enthusiast FlourishAnyway introduce some fun competition into the songs that have been spanned by countless artists by ranking them.

You are watching: Who sang over the rainbow on american idol


*

Some that the most beloved songs have been covered by a range of artists end the years. Us look in ~ Judy Garland's classic tune, "Over the Rainbow" and also rank 14 contenders. Who execute you prefer?

Simoneph via Pixabay, cost-free Domain


"Over the Rainbow" Is a post of Hope the Something better Awaits

In the 1930s, americans in the heartland feel the one-two beat of the an excellent Depression and the Dust Bowl. When days flourish dark, however, we Americans favor to depend on resilience in the confront of woe. As soon as storm clouds brew, we look for rainbows and silver linings. And when headwinds blow, we brace ourselves and lean right into them.


Beyond today's day-to-day troubles, something better awaits. The is the positive message relayed in this song. Possibly that's why the was named as

#1 on the songs of the 20th Century list by the Recording industry Association that America (RIAA) andthe greatest movie song ever by the American film Institute (AFI).

The original song title for "Over the Rainbow" was "Over the Rainbow Is wherein I desire to Be." Written especially for The wizard of Oz, the ditty was deleted from the movie three times since producers judged it too severe for the function of Dorothy, who was supposedly a son of 12. However, Judy Garland's voice coach and an associate producer believed in the song and teamed up in advocating tough for adding it back in.


That was the best move. "Over the Rainbow" ended up being not just Judy Garland's signature track but likewise won one Academy award for ideal Original Song. In the years because the top movie, the song has actually been recorded by thousands of artists. Versions encompass doo-wop, R&B, country, rock, hefty metal, and also everything in between. Fittingly, the was likewise the tune playing on gibbs Gene Wilder's deathbed. Find your favorite from among some the the many diverse and also most prominent versions together we watch at who sang the best.

"Who Sang that Best?": Here's how It Works

In the "Who Sang the Best?" series, we start with the initial version of well-known songs that have actually been spanned multiple times. Then we existing a collection of contenders, artist who have released sheathe versions in any type of genre. Some cover versions respect the original artist's style while others are reinterpretations.

Since the original song version is typically considered "the standard," we don't incorporate it in our as whole rankings. Instead, we screen it very first for comparison, through up come 14 contenders presented following in ranked order. Use the polls below to vote on your preferences:

Do you prefer the initial song or a sheathe version?Which the the covering versions carry out you prefer?

The standard Song


"Over the Rainbow" by Judy Garland (1939)

In the 1939 movie The sorcerer’s of Oz, Dorothy, the young character of Judy Garland, sings this classic tune before a tornado rips her from she Kansas house then transports her to the technicolor promise land of Oz. Trouble looms because that Dorothy, together she stand in the barnyard and reflects upon her dilemma. Anxious, Dorothy cannot control her lovely dog, Toto, native repeatedly gaining away from her. The dog has actually now bitten the vindictive townswoman, Mrs. Gulch, who has actually levied dangers to retaliate versus them both. ("I'll get you, mine pretty … and your tiny dog, too!)

With a feeling of soft melancholy, Dorothy imagines escaping she troubles. She mind floats come a dreamland she as soon as heard about in a lullaby. Garland channels her aspirations into the tune lyrics as if she life depends upon it. The song successfully embodies every the innocence and also earnestness that a 16-year-old girl.

For decades, the gold standard of this standard song has been Judy Garland's original. Can any kind of contender maybe beat it?

Reader Poll


1. "Over the Rainbow" by Eva Cassidy (2001)

Breathtaking and cherubic. Eva Cassidy blesses listeners with her gossamer-like vocals in this delicate and also wistful blues-tinged rendition the is end five and also a half minutes long. She sounds choose a sweet, clinically depressed point of view who requirements a sheep of Prozac. Through its distinct inflections, she breathes right into it a feeling of loss, hope, and far much more maturity than the original. Eva offers this tune the gift that perspective, and also this creatively rendered work-related of art sounds like an entirely different piece altogether. She elevates the song.

Add to this the listener's realization the this astonishingly talented woman bounced roughly the regional District that Columbia society circuit, unable to assistance herself by she music alone, before dying in loved one obscurity at period 33 indigenous melanoma that had actually spread to her bones. It to be our loss the songbird Eva Cassidy wasn't "discovered" till after she to be gone. In the time because her death, she recordings have actually sold end 10 million copies, and also she has because acquired well known fans, consisting of Paul McCartney, Michelle Kwan, and Eric Clapton.


2. "Over the Rainbow/What a wonderful World" by Israel ("Iz") Kamakawiwoʻole (1990)

Initially, it seems preposterous that a voice so delicate and otherworldly could come native a human being being in this packaging, but why not? indigenous Hawaiian Israel ("Iz") Kamakawiwoʻole brings a sense of wonder come his creative mashup of these two classic favorites v the steady, buoyant strumming that his small ukulele and his mesmerizing vocal lilt.


The decision to document this tune was a last minute one, and it profoundly changed both his life and legacy. Iz's version was provided in numerous films, television programs, and tv commercials varying from those because that deodorant to cars, soap come cereal.

The tune begins with his stunning rendition the Judy Garland's "Over the Rainbow," climate it melts seamlessly right into "What a exorbitant World," made famed in 1967 through jazz good Louis Armstrong. You'd never know they were two different songs written almost three years apart. His much more up-tempo method than Judy Garland creates an ext optimism. (I've always thought this variation would do a terrific, albeit unconventional, track for a funeral or memorial service.) Then, in the direction of the final couple of lines in the song, Iz artfully returns full circle come "Over the Rainbow."

You may an alert the video features circulation of Iz's ashes in the ocean. Weighing end 757 pounds in ~ his most difficult and about 500 pounds in ~ his death, he died of obesity-related causes in 1997 at age 38.


3. "Over the Rainbow" by frank Sinatra (1944)

Man, Ol' Blue Eyes reflects off his voice of velvet here. The wasn't also 30 year old however in this recording. Donate by singers and also an orchestra that sound prefer they're straight outta Disney's Bambi movie, Mr. Sinatra promotes this track to a work of art through his smooth voice that floats through numerous lines of extra text in the middle. Although that didn't creatively reimagine the song favor the an initial two contenders, his vocals room impeccable. Classy. Top-notch. Castle don't do 'em choose this anymore.


4."Over the Rainbow" through Jewel (2009)

Jewel starts this rendition the "Over the Rainbow" with a close to whisper, and she generously affords listeners the bonus of a little-known advent that Judy Garland sang only once in public. Did you know this little prelude existed?

When all the civilization is a hopeless jumble,And the raindrops tumble every around,Heaven opens a magic lane,When every the clouds darken up the skywayThere's a rainbow highway to be found,Leading indigenous your window pane.To a ar behind the sun, just a step beyond the rain.


Part the a arsenal of children's lullabies, Jewel's cover is enchanting in its emotional authenticity. Additionally, unimpeded by heavy music, this version allows Jewel's pristine voice come tiptoe, twirl, and also flutter its way acrobatically with the lyrics. (She was elevated by a yodeller climate operatically trained in college, for this reason vocal acrobatics are her forte.)

Jewel's donation is extremely solid and should remind the listener the this was an artist who was Grammy-nominated in two other genres. She's an expert, not a one-trick pony, and this is amongst her ideal work.


5. "Over the Rainbow" by Pink (2014)

Pink complied with in Jewel's footsteps and also included the hardly ever sung arrival to "Over the Rainbow" once she perform the classic tune in ~ the 2014 Academy Awards. It was the 75th anniversary solemn event of the Wizard that Oz movie's release, and among those in attendance to be Judy Garland's children, including daughter Liza Minelli.

The singer captivated her audience her raspy vocals and her emotional performance. Her voice was complete of gusto, and also at points, it simply soared. There to be no question that Pink to be imaging what the lyrics intended within context of her very own dreams. Then she walk in because that the huge ending, an initiative that was divine and deserving the the stand ovation she received.


6. "Over the Rainbow" by Eric Clapton (2001)

Whereas some renditions of "Over the Rainbow" room melancholy, this one is not. It's miscellaneous you have the right to sway to, a smoky, laid-back R&B rendition heavy on hope and also recorded live in concert. Clapton is chillin' v his guitar doing what that does best. (And if friend look closely, you'll an alert he's put on tennis shoes. Only a male of a details age who has stopped offering a paris f*ck around what people think does that, and you need to respect him for that.) The man, the voice, the legend.


7. "Over the Rainbow" through Patti LaBelle & The Bluebells (1966)

Although she waited till 1977 to launch she solo career, lead singer Patti LaBelle renders it clean in this tune that she does not need earlier up, say thanks to you. The woman has some an effective pipes, and she offers them below to include hurt come this sluggish rendition the "Over the Rainbow." The only an unfavorable thing is the ineffective doo-wop sing-song effect included by her back-up singers. If anything, it accentuates LaBelle's superior vocal talent.


8. "Over the Rainbow" by Trisha Yearwood (2018)

Country star Trisha Yearwood bring in one orchestra to ago her up and does yeoman's work in replicating the standard song. However while her rendition is pleasant enough she plays it safe and does not take chances vocally beyond belting out the line, "Somewhere end the rainbow." Yearwood sidesteps the possibility to reimagine this song with a fresh method like some other singers, therefore I discovered her contribution to lack creativity and compelling emotionally depth in compare to higher ranked contenders. Sorry, Trish.


9. "Over the Rainbow/What a wonderful World" by Cliff Richard (2001)

They to speak imitation is the highest kind of flattery. The very same artist who brought us the 1976 pop hit "Devil Woman" supplies this positive, uplifting, sheathe of Judy Garland's original. In it, he channels Iz's spirit, minus the ukelele, and also offers a rock variation of Israel Kamakawiwoʻole's blending of "Over the Rainbow" and "What a wonderful World." Although i wish Richard available something various vocally than merely trying come imitate one more musician's sound, his voice floated effortlessly with the song, and I liked the rock instrumentals.


10. "Over the Rainbow" by Katharine McPhee (2006)

At the very least she wasn't a one-hit wonder. Katharine McPhee was the runner-up ~ above the 5th season of American Idol, and also her 2006 sheathe of "Over the Rainbow" peaked in ~ #12 top top the Billboard warm 100, adhered to the next year by "Over It." After numerous years of no having any other hits on the Billboard hot 100, she turned her attention to acting and also Broadway. (I believe her talent is well inserted there.)

McPhee's rendition that "Over the Rainbow" performed well on the chart, yet rather 보다 a genuine attempt to convey an emotional experience, it was rather an exercise in vocal gymnastics. Granted, if she's particularly great at hitting her marks once it concerns those high notes, McPhee seems to it is in going with the mere motions. Vocally, she seems to be saying, "Look what I can do!" and relies entirely upon too lot vibrato. Her variation lacks the capability to important connect, and I uncovered it reasonably standard.


11. "Over the Rainbow" by Pentatonix (2017)

When they started off with "do do do do," i was already thinking "no no no no." since they to explode on the step in 2011 as winners of NBC's The Sing-Off, Pentatonix has us for this reason spoiled through their unbelievable a capella renditions of well-known songs that when they create one that's simply average, it's a bitterness disappointment. This cover lacks your usual spark, and particularly later in the song, it i do not care clear the there are too numerous people associated in this venture.


12 "Over the Rainbow" by The Geezinslaws (1990)

I promise this is different from any type of version you've ever before heard. If you desire a creative interpretation the "Over the Rainbow," below it is by Austin, Texas-based country music comedy duo The Geezinslaws. Castle performed with each other for over 5 decades.

Some could say lock slaughtered the song. Ns say if you gain bluegrass-tinged nation music then you'll appreciate this together a wildly reimagined cover the Judy Garland would have actually never doubt (as if she'd have actually expected a ginormous Hawaiian male with a ukelele come cover it.) their cover has a "hoedown" style contagious beat. Also if this is no your layout of music, something is wrong through you if you're no toe-tapping through the end of the song. Happen the cornbread and also give that a listen, even if it's simply for the shock value.


13. "Over the Rainbow" by The Demensions (1960)

The Dimensions transformed "Over the Rainbow" as a doo-wop song. It was their greatest charted single, increasing to #16 top top the Billboard hot 100. Due to the fact that they had no other songs that hit the Billboard warm 100, consider them one-hit wonders.

I discovered that the doo-wop ditty ide of this song worked better than its reality. The members of the quartet sang end one another, so it was challenging to clearly understand several of their words in ~ times even though i knew the lyrics. Also, the song seemed to drag, and it got an unappealing "sing song" quality. Return the listener it s okay the point within the first minute the the song, it was worth a listen.


14. "Over the Rainbow" by Rufus Wainwright

This rendition is so hefty on the hurt the it's difficult to hear to. Rufus sings favor he has actually a killer migraine. (Do you notification him stop his head and also stroking his confront in a self-comforting manner?)

He draws out his text dramatically—I didn't to speak effectively, simply dramatically—and he fails to enunciate his words. Friend would need to be a die-hard fan to savor this offering. Play it ~ above repeat might make a good albeit unusual form of punishment because that uncooperative prisoners. They'd say "uncle" quite quickly. Don't punish yourself by listening come this track too intensely.


Questions & Answers

Question: exactly how are contender songs selected? ns was wonder why this well known Australian rock star, Billy Thorpe (now deceased) did no make the list?

Answer: "Who Sang it Best?" is a series, and also for each tune I present the initial song to add 14 who likewise recorded the tune (I contact these artists "contenders"). There is no scientific process for picking contenders. Indeed, there are sometimes numerous artists who have actually recorded a song. Thus, I shot to pick some the the most well-known versions and also a few by popular artists the didn't seem come garner a most attention. Also, I shot to stand for multiple category (rock, country, pop, and also sometimes even metal artists), and sometimes I'll include particularly surprising version, either good or bad. In every one of this, ns guess Billy Thorpe simply didn't come up for this song. I try to permit an "Other" choice for the competitor vote and also encourage comments in the Comments section so that readers can surface various other versions they like. I'm including the link to Thorpe's rendition because that those who desire to listen. Https://youtu.be/m62gip2biWs


Rachelle - I'm glad that belief Hill was your favorite. Many thanks for stopping by.

Rachelle on august 24, 2020:

I love belief Hill's version.

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA on august 03, 2020:

Matthew - He's really talented.

Matthew on respectable 02, 2020:

Mandy Patinkin

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on may 21, 2020:

sperry - thank you for such one enthusiastic, resounding endorsement of her favorite version. It's exorbitant to hear someone have actually such respect and also passion for Judy Garland and the actress who portrayed her brilliantly.

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA on might 21, 2020:

Mik411 - say thanks to you for chiming in.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on may 21, 2020:

Bru Benson - say thanks to you for her perspective.


sperry on may 20, 2020:

Since this post: The Movie Judy has earned an Oscar for Renée Zellweger portraying just a couple of weeks in The great Judy Garland's life. Renee also sang a variation of over The rainbow while sit on the stage side and also the crowd sang it earlier to her. Absolutely heart wrenching that one was. Nobody has ever before done it better than Judy every single time she sang it--it is Judy Judy Judy all the way Renee is the closestly ever and the rest are just feeling your "Judy" v her song... I have actually times where I will certainly sing that too--but Judy Garland is the execute All, finish All, Be every one of of Somewhere end the Rainbow!


Mik411 on may 20, 2020:

Israel Kamakawiwoʻole to be by much the ideal one. I'll put Pink second.

Bru Benson on might 20, 2020:

Don Potter

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on may 17, 2020:

AairesBob - thanks for chiming in.

AairesBob on may 17, 2020:

My choice, by far, is Melody Gardot. Check it out.


FlourishAnyway (author) from USA ~ above April 12, 2020:

Dave Hogestyn - thanks for chiming in.

Dave Hogestyn on April 11, 2020:

Don Potter's version is wonderful

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA on in march 15, 2020:

Peggy - many thanks for weighing in about your favorite. Judy Garland to be a tragic heart with a beautiful voice.

Peggy Woods from Houston, Texas on march 15, 2020:

It is hard to acquire away native the truth of Judy Garland do that tune iconic in nature. If other people with great voices additionally sing it, Judy's version will constantly be my favorite.


FlourishAnyway (author) from USA top top February 08, 2020:

Mark BA - Everyone has their very own rationales, so that's why I do a voting section and also comments section. Many thanks for weighing in!

Mark BA top top February 08, 2020:

This to be fun. Now, for my 2 cents. Of the contenders, I wanted Trisha Yearwood's cover, for the specific reason that you knocked it. As the saying goes, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." i felt Trisha's was closest to Garland's.


For best an individual interpretation, when I prefer the rock sound, I have actually to provide credit whereby credit is due. So, if I preferred Cliff Richard's rendition, it to be a sheathe of a cover. Thumbs as much as Iz.

I look front to "playing along" with various other songs.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA top top October 30, 2019:

Lora - she voice is therefore beautiful. It's tragic that she died not knowing how famed her tune version would certainly become. Thanks for taking a look. Have actually a great week.

Lora Hollings ~ above October 29, 2019:

I've always loved the way that Judy Garland sang this song and also because little Toto remained in that scene with her, and also she to be so mesmerizing together the girl indigenous Kansas in among the greatest films ever, i would need to say that she gets my vote together the best when it concerns this song. But I was just amazed in ~ the remarkable voice of Eva Cassidy and also her beautiful interpretation. Give thanks to you grow for a exorbitant time in listening come this beautiful song and introducing me come this brand-new singer I had actually never heard of but who ns will need to hear an ext from. Good job!


Anonymous - thanks for registering her favorite. She does have actually a lover voice.

Anonymous on October 29, 2019:

Jane Monheit

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on October 28, 2019:

BigDaddyCool - thanks for chiming in on her favorite. Store singing and also take good care that yourself.

BigdaddyCool top top October 28, 2019:

For me personally it's Israel, it's absolutely impressive a guy so huge had a voice to match. I've cry multiple time to his version, the just one that's done the to me. I myself to be a big man, about 300lbs and also at mine heaviest around 425lbs. Ironically i deserve to sing part myself and sound closer come Israel than any of the other artists on this list. Take treatment everyone and many blessings~

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA top top September 29, 2019:

Zak - thanks for her perspective.

Zak on September 29, 2019:

Patti LaBelle in the 80s and after

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA on September 12, 2019:


Tamara - I'm glad you appreciated this and also learned something. I hope you uncovered some brand-new renditions to listen to, favor Iz's. He is spectacular.

Tamara Yancosky native Uninhabited regions on September 12, 2019:

I love this enchanting song and didn’t recognize that so many others, besides Judy Garland, sang it. I constantly learn something new on my visits to her site!

Hugs,

Tamara

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA on might 28, 2019:

David - thanks for your comment.

David on may 28, 2019:

Jackie Evancho. She did song it in ~ the induction awareness for track of the century.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on April 15, 2019:

Nell - thanks for weighing in. Have actually a wonderful week!

Nell Rose indigenous England top top April 15, 2019:

It has to be Iz(israel) ideal but ns listened come PInk and thought the was a good version too! an excellent list and also songs as always.


Nithya - I prefer hearing every one of the various conjurations of these songs, as occasionally artists can fully transform an initial work. Thank you for preventing by and also speaking up because that Cliff Richards' version.

Nithya Venkat indigenous Dubai on April 12, 2019:

I love over the Rainbow sung through Cliff Richards, his rendition of the track is the best! ns enjoy reading the information you carry out with each song.

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA top top April 10, 2019:

Dora - thanks for listening. Ns am happy you enjoyed this.

Dora Weithers from The Caribbean ~ above April 09, 2019:

Beautiful classic and also so many good singers. The Pentatonix may not it is in number one here, yet I still favor their presentation. Thanks for the music.

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA top top April 09, 2019:

Dianna - I appreciate your type kudos. Have a wonderful week!

Dianna Mendez ~ above April 08, 2019:


For me, Judy Garland sings it choose no other yet Yearwood and also Jewel have seconds here. Thanks for pass a laugh to mine evening through the beloved versions that this beautiful song.


FlourishAnyway (author) from USA ~ above April 07, 2019:

Genna - give thanks to you for protecting against by. I hope you were able to uncover some various ones that you liked, too. Have actually a an excellent week!

Genna East indigenous Massachusetts, USA on April 07, 2019:

Hi Flourish...

The moment I check out the title, I believed Judy Garland. However you have provided us various other wonderful performances as well. Give thanks to you!

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA top top April 05, 2019:

Linda - He had actually such a beautiful voice and also did much to promote the sounds of aboriginal Hawaiians. I'm glad you took pleasure in this.

Linda Crampton native British Columbia, Canada top top April 04, 2019:

I've never ever heard the singer in the 2nd video before. Give thanks to you for presenting me to him, Flourish. I'm going come explore more of his songs.


FlourishAnyway (author) from USA ~ above April 04, 2019:

Audrey, an especially coming from you that method a entirety bunch. Ns love hear everyone's different perspectives on that they reap the most. This is such a beautiful song. Have actually a exorbitant weekend.


FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA on April 04, 2019:

Dolores - exactly how lucky you are to have had that experience! thank you for sharing both that and also your opinion.

Dolores Monet from eastern Coast, United says on April 04, 2019:

Though ns have always loved Judy Garland, spent hours listening to she Live in ~ Carnegie Hall once I was young, I need to vote for Eva. If I just think of her voice to sing this song, ns tear up.

Audrey Hunt indigenous Pahrump NV top top April 03, 2019:

There's no contest when it comes to singing this classic. Judy Garland reigns! Her technique is flawless, unlike many of her rivals. My an option for a cover variation is more than likely Eva Cassidy, adhered to by Katherine McPhee. My apologies to mine Hawaiin friend, "Iz" who is no longer with us, because that not consisting of you right here You know how much ns love you and also your amazing voice and also style.


Flourish, this is an incredible job you've done. Among my favorites!

I'll be posting this ~ above my on facebook singing page, along with my an individual page.

Thanks ever before so much. Outstanding!

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA ~ above April 03, 2019:


Heidi - who who procedures up because that Judy Garland's version! In researching this article, ns read about what a catastrophic life she had actually ... Alleged abuse through the munchkins on set, dreadful criticism by movie executives around her weight, medicine dependency, several divorces, psychological illness and also suicide attempts. Regardless, it's an exceptional song. Shirley temple was initially sought for the function but she wasn't easily accessible and couldn't fight the high notes. Have actually a an excellent week!

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA on April 03, 2019:

Peg - thank you for weighing in. It's a lovely song. It would be quite to be able to exit this civilization like Gene Wilder with this playing in the background.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA ~ above April 03, 2019:

Linda - it seems favor that once artists feeling a particular song, they nail it ~ above the first take. Ns long thought that no one could beat Judy Garland's yet have been pleasantly surprised in ~ the variety and quality of numerous of the offerings -- and also amused through some. Thanks for reading.


Suzie from Carson City ~ above April 03, 2019:

Flourish....I deserve to only shot to imagine. .and hope someday we'll all experience it! :)

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA on April 03, 2019:


Lori - His is so buoyant and lovely! many thanks for protecting against by. I hope friend write much more poetry soon.

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA on April 03, 2019:

Kaili - Classy for sure!

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA top top April 03, 2019:

Paula - She and also Aretha! have the right to you imagine?

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA top top April 03, 2019:

Bill - Aww. Sorry about the tears. It's a beautiful song.

Heidi Thorne from Chicago Area on April 03, 2019:

I'm walking old school on this one! LOVE the Judy Garland version due to the fact that it's burnished in my memory with one of my favourite movie classics. Happy Wednesday!

Suzie indigenous Carson City ~ above April 03, 2019:


Oh Flourish....I'll never stop grieving the lose of this amazing woman through the voice of one "Angel"....which she at some point & actually became. I'm sure she's the command singer of the whole Choir that Angels....

Peg Cole from north Dallas, Texas on April 03, 2019:

I for sure love this song and anyone that sings it. If i were to choose an all time favorite, it would certainly be Eva Cassidy. Her variation is awesome.


Linda Lum indigenous Washington State, USA on April 03, 2019:

Flourish, I had no idea that this song had been extended by so plenty of artists. The initial version is, the course, very sweet and also tender. When you review the stories of Judy Garland's life it seems fitting that this is she signature song.The Pentatonix disappoints--I didn't even listen to the entire recording. Eva's is sweet and also heartbreaking. What a tragedy the she passed away so young and also as one unknown. Iz had actually an amazing tender voice because that such a large human being. Walk you recognize that his recording was done in one take? It's difficult to choose a favorite. Deserve to I split it 3 ways?

Lori Staley Truzy native Raleigh, NC ~ above April 03, 2019:

Iz is the finest by far

Kaili Bisson from Canada top top April 03, 2019:

Sinatra, no contest :-)

Bill Holland native Olympia, WA top top April 03, 2019:

I'm no going through the classic this time, however with Israel. His version always makes me cry.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA ~ above April 03, 2019:

Paula, Isn't she just phenomenal? It's practically like there's a part of her that knew it simply wasn't meant to be.


FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA on April 03, 2019:

Pamela - since this group of song is ranked, I'm glad the was her reaction! There's one screamo variation by an unnamed artist the is important a awful version. It's cringeworthy, nearly laughable in a way. I've heard some fatality metal versions, too, that made me just ask, "Why?" The diverse approaches come the track are interesting, however everything has its limits.

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA top top April 03, 2019:

Shannon - through this track being called the tune of the 20th century and all, i felt it almost sacrilegious come say Eva Cassidy sang it better, but she yes, really nailed it. Many thanks for mentioning Linda Eder's version. Ns haven't heard that it yet will go look it up.

FlourishAnyway (author) from USA on April 03, 2019:

Bill - I'm amazing by how these artist can offer the exact same song such a various flavor. Ns was additionally pleasantly surprised at Pink's performance. You need to hear she cover Janis Joplin's "Me & Bobby McGee."

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA on April 03, 2019:

Clive - say thanks to you for your comment.

FlourishAnyway (author) indigenous USA ~ above April 03, 2019:


John - She yes, really hits it out of the park here. I evaluate your avoiding by! thank you.

Suzie native Carson City top top April 03, 2019:

Flourish......Hands down! Eva Cassidy....no doubt. No competition. Eva (rest her soul) sang the most incredibly, beautiful, moving, emotional, heart-wrenching variation of this song, EVER! just as she does, every track she ever sang. Many thanks for asking!

She's my really favorite singer, musician, mrs artist. I love Eva. I'm betting she wins!

Peace, Paula

FlourishAnyway (author) native USA top top April 03, 2019:

Liz - say thanks to you for reading.

John Hansen indigenous Gondwana soil on April 03, 2019:

What a wonderful track to choose, Flourish. The original will constantly be classic but I voted because that Jewel's together my favourite, carefully followed by Pink's. Thanks for presenting this wonderful versions.

Clive Williams from Jamaica ~ above April 02, 2019:

beautiful song

Pamela Oglesby from clear Florida on April 02, 2019:


I walk not recognize so many civilization sang this song. I favored the first few and Trisha Yearwood, yet not the last couple of as much. I guess ns am old fashioned together I favored the initial song quite well. This is sure an exciting group of song Flouish.

Shannon Henry indigenous Texas ~ above April 02, 2019:

Who doesn't prefer Eva Cassidy's version? Far much better than the original, which is type of rare, ns think. I likewise like Jewel's version. I've constantly loved she voice. Come answer your question, ns did not understand that prelude existed till now. Isreal's version was fun and also funky, very enjoyable. Pink did superb job. Never heard Clapton's version before, however I chosen it a lot. Good Ol' frank disappointed me here and also I didn't treatment for Patti's version either. Pentatonix, well, they deserve to do therefore much much better than that and also I don't know what come say about my allow down with them. The rest are okay.

Excellent selections you found of this song. Have you ever heard Linda Eder's version? I ended up being a fan of hers well over a decade earlier when ns heard her song "Vienna."

Bill De Giulio native Massachusetts top top April 02, 2019:

Hi Flourish. One of my all-time favorites. Judy Garland’s variation will constantly be mine favorite, but I must say the version by Eva Cassidy was incredible. I had actually never heard the her and also how sad that she died so young before the human being discovered she talent. I in reality enjoyed numerous of the performances, specifically Frank Sinatra and also surprisingly Pink. Great job together always.

See more: Microscope Coarse Adjustment Knob And Fine Adjustment Knob S?

Liz Westwood indigenous UK top top April 02, 2019:

I had actually no idea there to be so plenty of cover versions. When again, your research study is impressive.